Let’s begin by reminding ourselves just how detached from nature we have become. We (excluding vegans) are completely detached from the death of the animals we eat. I myself have read Jonathan Safran Foer’s “Eating Animals,” a detailed explanation of how cruel, immoral, unhealthy and unsustainable factory farming (99.9% of all our meat’s origin) is, and I still eat meat. I am a part of the problem, and I myself am detached from nature.
That being said, when I heard that people were insulting the sport of hunting and issuing death threats to a man who shot a Lion in Zimbabwe, I was outraged, as I always am by the court of Twitter opinion. Let’s get all the details down, as far as we currently know:
Walter Palmer, the hunter from the US who went to Zimbabwe, hired guides to set up the hunt, and paid them roughly 65,000$ CAD.
Palmer and his guides lured Cecil the lion, apparently a known Zimbabwe attraction which no one issuing death threats knew existed until after his death, by strapping a dead animal to their vehicle and drawing Cecil out.
While this is a known tactic to dodge the rules within the parks like the one Cecil was inside of, the men Palmer hired apparently did not have a hunting permit to do this.
His guides are being charged for not having a permit, while Palmer has not been charged with a crime.
Cecil was 13 years old, and the average life span of a lion is between 10 to 12 years.
Keep in mind that animals, these lions included, are shot every hour of every day by hunters around the world, not to mention the billions of factory farmed animals living lives so horrible that Cecil’s last few days look enjoyable in comparison. Yet there is no push to end factory farming, and we only hear about people’s hateful opinion on hunting when a “special” or “endangered” one is killed.
Here are some journalists hypocritically saying they don’t “usually” support mobs, but they encourage people to mob this man:
I have never supported an Internet mob as much as I support the Internet mob coming for Dr. Walter Palmer
— Elias Isquith (@eliasisquith) July 28, 2015
I'm against online mobs as a general rule, but Walter Palmer deserves all of the public shaming: http://t.co/nbRMeurIAB
— Jill Filipovic (@JillFilipovic) July 28, 2015
Here is Glenn Greenwald, who’s anti-government messages I approve of, insulting the man who he has never even met or spoken to:
It's deeply insecure & inadequate men attempting to compensate & derive self-esteem through cowardice & slaughter. https://t.co/BEOo1ZlTH1
— Glenn Greenwald (@ggreenwald) July 28, 2015
Palmer’s neighborhood and business are on lockdown. This man’s life has been changed forever.
— Paul Blume (@PaulBlume_FOX9) July 30, 2015
Dental practice belonging to controversial big game hunter Walter Palmer completely locked down. All shades drawn. pic.twitter.com/opvzJp8ea9
— Paul Blume (@PaulBlume_FOX9) July 28, 2015
I do not know Mr. Palmer. I do not care to worry that he has apparently gotten into legal trouble because of his hunting in the past. These personal attacks (and death threats…), towards a man who by all logic attempted to legally shoot an animal like so many other hunters do, highlight the cruelty and violence within the anti-hunting community. How ironic.
I want to quickly turn to a story from just a few months ago. Corey Knowlton, who you can see explaining all of this in detail with Joe Rogan here, bid 350,000$ US to shoot an endangered black rhino.
Holy fuck, Knowlton not only paid 7 times as much as Palmer to kill the animal, but it’s endangered! Oh my god! Queue the insults and anti-hunting, anti-Knowlton mob:
Let's be honest #CoreyKnowlton you paid $350,000 for the thrill, not for conservation, and fact that you justify it that way is nauseating.
— Bethany Vinton (@bethanyvinton) May 20, 2015
Corey Knowlton of Texas bid $350,000 to kill a black rhino. He says conservation hunting "protects rhinos". I say abortions "prevent Coreys"
— Ryan (@TheRyanDiBiase) May 20, 2015
Corey Knowlton- Feel good now you've shot your rhino? – the rest of us dont now that we are 1 closer to extinction! pic.twitter.com/Fru7qFY87j
— Karen Laurence-Rowe (@mamachui2) May 20, 2015
Yes, Knowlton did kill the rhino in the name of conservation. The fact is that the specific rhino that he bid on and killed was a huge alpha male killing the other males, females and calves. It may sound counter-intuitive when you read a 50 character tweet by an angry member of the court of public opinion, but believe it or not, not all endangered animals like to peacefully co-exist as we would like them to.
Add to this that the money he bid, which Knowlton received from sponsors, has to go through many checks to make sure the money went towards the conservation of these animals. Rather than asking all the angry people on twitter to raise 350,000$ so they could then try to peacefully remove this rhino somehow, we instead had a solution in which the country auctions the life of the problematic animal for as much as they can, so they get more money for conservation, while simultaneously fixing the current problem that really has no other solution.
Oh, and the rhino was fed to the local villagers, who were extremely thankful. I highly recommend the Joe Rogan podcast he did which I linked above, as it is mind-blowing to see how these issues are poorly presented in the mainstream media, and even to this day if you google Knowlton’s name you will only see negative, hateful content.
I presented the facts for Palmer’s lion case in detail, and it’s clear that these are two different cases. That being said, a quick google search on Knowlton’s black rhino still yields incredibly one-sided, hateful, slanderous results. This means that the information we have is biased, and drawing an opinion, trying to ruin someone’s business, insulting their manhood and other qualities, and threatening their lives is something no one should be doing.
Cecil was going to die in the wild soon anyways. If you don’t think this is a good argument, or if you think that what Palmer did was cruel, I dare you to watch this for more than a few seconds:
The screaming is the deer. Try to finish the video. It’s very difficult for most people, and that’s because we have been so removed from nature that witnessing some of its aspects is shocking to us. If we spent money putting the faces of animals on buildings every time one died in nature, we would have no money for things we actually need.
Cecil’s fate is just like our fate. We make death as comfortable for us as we can (at a huge cost, mind you), and we simply can’t expect that for every single last beautiful animal on the planet. I mentioned that Knowlton was sponsored for his 350,000$ bid. That’s because the man is an expert in the field of hunting. He had his own TV show about hunting. He is trained to kill an animal as quickly and efficiently as possible, in an unarguably less torturous way than in the video above.
The court of Twitter thinks these men are trying to bolster their manliness. Even if they are, it is ridiculous to judge them, to threaten them, to try to make their lives worse, just because you read an article that frames this entire situation from the perspective of an ill-informed child.